7746 Menomonee River Parkway is a triangular quarter-acre lot near Tosa Village. It used to hold an office building. The city bought it in 2020 and cleared it so housing could go up, according to BizTimes. In the six years since, one developer after another has drawn plans for the lot, and a good share of those plans were aimed at owners. What is now being built there is rental housing.
For anyone in Wauwatosa thinking about leaving a detached house for something smaller, that lot answers a practical question. A buyer who wants to own a condo or townhome in Tosa is shopping the homes that already exist. The city recorded no new condominium plats from 2023 through 2025, and the looser condo market elsewhere in the metro hasn't reached the city.
BizTimes listed the earlier attempts when the city chose a developer in September 2025. Galbraith Carnahan Architects proposed four luxury townhomes in 2023 and later withdrew them. Striegel Agacki Studio, Klein Development Inc. and Hintz Holdings also submitted bids. Striegel Agacki came back with a revised plan in 2025, and the city did not move it forward.
The plan that came closest to new for-sale housing arrived in July 2025. Tenderland Real Estate proposed a four-story building with nine two-bedroom condos of about 800 to 1,000 square feet each, priced at roughly $450,000 apiece, BizTimes reported. That works out to about $450 to $560 per square foot for a new two-bedroom in the Village. The proposal asked for tax incremental financing and a full land donation, and city officials called that combination a "non-starter."
The Community Development Authority voted unanimously that September to name JJH3group and Galbraith Carnahan the preferred team. Their plan pairs four rowhouses with a separate 10-apartment building. JJH3group president Jeffrey Hook told BizTimes the rowhomes were meant for empty nesters who want to downsize without leaving the neighborhood. Mayor Dennis McBride, in the same article, said the run of false starts "reflects the broader challenges we see across the metro area, and the country in financing condominiums."
The empty nesters Hook described will be renters. In the city's 2026 financing file, the project, now called Sonne, is 14 rental units:
| Unit type | Count | Size | Projected monthly rent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Three-story townhouse, 2 bed / 2.5 bath, over a 2-car garage | 4 | about 1,620 sq ft in the city file | about $4,800 |
| One-bedroom apartment | 3 | 800 sq ft | about $2,000 |
| One-bedroom apartment | 4 | 900 sq ft | about $2,250 |
| One-bedroom apartment | 3 | 950 sq ft | about $2,375 |
The developer puts total project cost at $6,490,341, or about $464,000 per unit, and the request includes roughly $880,000 in pay-as-you-go TIF support. City staff described Sonne as a "missing middle housing project on an extremely difficult site," and as a project type "the market has largely failed to deliver." The Common Council approved the TIF term sheet on April 28, 2026, and the Design Review Board approved the design on September 17. Galbraith Carnahan's project page lists Sonne as under construction and describes the townhomes as larger, at about 2,500 square feet, while the city file targets occupancy for October 2027.
Look at the citywide numbers and the Village lot turns out to be typical. Wauwatosa's Housing Affordability Report, dated January 2026, shows zero condominium plats in 2023, in 2024 and in 2025. Over the same three years, certified survey maps covered 412, 959 and 555 units.
The same report lists the larger projects expected to be underway in 2026: 523 units at the Mayfair Collection Foundry, 196 at Mayfair and Wisconsin, 92 at 2825 Mayfair, 41 for Le Bon Vivant, and 918 at Mayfair Mall phased over ten years. A downsizer who wants to own in Tosa should confirm with the developer whether any unit in these projects will be offered for sale before counting it as an option.
None of this is new. The city's housing needs analysis found unmet demand for for-sale condominiums and townhomes, "largely desired by those looking to downsize from detached single-family homes." It also recorded agents saying that buyers looking for that kind of home often had to buy outside the city. The Village lot shows why the gap has lasted. A well-located site with public help still came out as a rental.
With nothing new coming, a Tosa downsizer is buying from a supply that turns over slowly and sells quickly. The Greater Milwaukee Association of Realtors' municipal statistics, released this month, show 423 residential sales in Wauwatosa from January through September 2026. The same period had 494 sales in 2025, 641 in 2022 and 700 in 2021. That is roughly 40 percent fewer sales than in the first nine months of 2021. Prices kept rising anyway. GMAR's price figure for those nine months is $480,063, up from $450,290 a year earlier, and homes averaged 12 days on market compared with 14. These figures cover single-family homes, two-family homes, multifamily buildings and condominiums together.
The wider metro is moving the other way. In October 2026, condos and townhouses across Milwaukee, Ozaukee, Washington and Waukesha counties had 942 active listings, up 15.3 percent from October 2025. Months of supply rose 29.7 percent to 3.8, and average days on market reached 36, according to the Metro MLS October summary. The four-county median condo price that month was $310,150. GMAR's October release put the four-county metro at 3.4 months of seasonally adjusted inventory.
A buyer reading those metro numbers could reasonably expect more condo choices and more time to decide. Wauwatosa's figures through September point the other way, with fewer sales and a shorter average time on market than a year earlier, and the city recorded no new condominium plats in the three years before that.
With no new condo plats recorded from 2023 through 2025, the Village lot gives a Tosa downsizer two reference prices. The first is roughly $450,000 for a new two-bedroom of 800 to 1,000 square feet, the price Tenderland put on a building the city passed over. The second is $4,800 a month, the projected rent for a new Sonne townhouse over a two-car garage, or about $57,600 a year.
A resale condo or smaller house in Wauwatosa competes with both. When a well-kept resale comes in under what new construction would have cost, it is the only way to own something of that size in Tosa without starting from scratch, and the 12-day average suggests sellers know it. If a buyer is mainly paying for being new, Sonne's rents give them a way to have that without owning. Sorting the listings into those two groups usually tells a downsizer where to compete hard and where to wait.
The other half of the decision is the house being sold. A downsizer selling a detached Tosa home is selling into the same thin supply, at prices still rising through September 2026. Our 2026 look at Wauwatosa's median price explains why that one number hides big differences between parts of the city. A current valuation of your own house is a sounder starting point than the citywide figure. Households that need to buy before they sell can look at buying and selling at the same time and our bridge loan resources.
No. The city's April 2026 financing file describes all 14 units at 7746 Menomonee River Parkway as rentals. That includes the four townhouses, which are projected at about $4,800 a month.
Only a little. The October 2026 Metro MLS summary shows condo and townhouse listings up 15.3 percent for the four counties combined. Wauwatosa added no new condo plats from 2023 through 2025, and its homes sold in an average of 12 days through September 2026.
If you're thinking about trading a Wauwatosa house for something smaller and want to stay in Tosa, The Shar Borg Team can help with both halves of the move. We'll get your current home ready for market through our concierge process and keep watch on the Tosa resale homes that fit the next chapter, with downsizing support built in. Request a complimentary concierge consultation.